August 21, 2005

In Defense of Freedom


I came across an interesting article in the The Scotsman this morning entitled "Famine Is Offensive, Not Jerry Springer". In a response to the Christian protest against the "Jerry Springer: The Opera" which may (or may not) have led to the loss of arts funding by the British Arts Council, the author (a self-proclaimed "non-Christian") considers the nature of Christianity against Christ. In his opening paragraph, Andrew Burnet says:

"For a non-Christian, I take a pretty positive view of Christianity. I mean, it's obvious, isn't it, that if everyone lived according to the proposals put forward in the Sermon on the Mount, we'd live in a much more pleasant, equitable world?"

He goes on the speculate that Jesus is not so concerned with many of the things Christian invest time, energy and money into protesting, stating:

"I can't help feeling, too, that he's pretty indifferent to alleged blasphemy in the arts. My hunch is, he would have enjoyed Monty Python's Life of Brian"

Inevitably, Christian readers will find some views of the writer harder to swallow than others, but it is quite rare to find an admittedly non-Christian writer, who is critiquing the Church, but graciously honours the exceptions to this critique and recognizes that Jesus Himself should not be measured by those who represent Him poorly. I wonder if many Christians would be so gracious.

So how do those of us who seek to represent Christ & Christianity in a more authentic way respond to such an article? Do we apologize for those who have so brutally misused the name of Jesus, both now and through history? Do we argue against the sweeping generalizations? Do we formulate an apologetic for Christianity as we see it (be it Emergent or what have you)?

Perhaps all of these things, in part, can and should be part of our response. However, I do not believe it is either enough nor the emphasis we should seek. Rather, if such public displays of unfortunate Christianity can draw the attention of a watching world, then let us change their hearts and minds with missional communities that distinguish themselves by that which they believe is True, not just what is simply good, right or moral.

Even further, I wonder if we should be distinguishing ourselves by standing beside those whose freedoms are threatened, even if those freedoms are exercised in ways we may be uncomfortable with or are disagreeable with our morality? This is not to say that we throw the doors open to unbridled permisiveness. Rather, acknowledging the complex and sensitive balance that needs to be found, create a world in which free will can be exercised responsibly and truly- meaning room must be made to fail. The Tree was in the Garden, after all.

It is not that we want to become "politcally correct" or even "socially acceptable", but neither do we want to protect against the abuse of freedom by removing freedom altogether. Martin Luther King Jr. once said of racial segregation:

"Morality cannot be legislated, but behaviour can be regulated... Desegregation will break down the legal barriers and bring men together physically, but something must touch the hearts and souls of men so that they will come together spiritually because it is natural and right. A vigorous enforcement of civil rights laws will bring an end to segregated public facilities, which are barriers to a truly desegregated society, but it cannot bring an end to fear, prejudice, pride, and irrationality, which are barriers to a truly integrated society.

"These dark and demonic responses will be removed only as men are possessed by by the invisible, inner law which etches on their hearts the conviction that all men are brothers and that love is mankind's most potent weapon for personal and social transformation. True integration will be achieved by true neighbours who are willingly obedient to unenforcable obligations."
('Strength To Love', Pocket Book, 1968)

In the same way, while laws and rules may serve the ultimate good (though rarely when it hinders true freedom), they must be byproducts of this deeper, truer obedience to the unenforcable obligations of the loving God and loving our neighbours.
Posted by Jamie Arpin-Ricci at 18:02:36 | Permanent Link | Comments (17) |
Comments
1 - You would really appreciate Jacques Ellul's "Propaganda"; "The Ethics of Freedom"; and "The Presence of the Kingdom" which is quoted here,

"If we let ourselves drift along the stream of history, without knowing it, we shall have chosen the power of suicide, which is at the heart of the world.... In order to preserve the world, it is actually necessary that a genuine revolution take place."

Ellul was a Christian in France before, during and after WWII. He was the first French professor allowed to teach on Marx. He was the professor of Roman Laws and Institutions at U of Bordeaux. An incredible revolutionary in so many socio- economic- political- activistic- spiritual ways. A mayor, prof, pastor of a house church, etc... I love radicals and saints.

Good post. (Comment this)

Written by: kbartha at 2005/08/22 - 03:50:02
2 - kbartha,

Thanks for the references and the quote. Have you read "Subversive Orthodoxy" by Robert Inchausti? You might like it (link in my books to the right).

Peace,
Jamie (Comment this)

Written by: Jamie Arpin-Ricci at 2005/08/22 - 04:07:57
3 - Havn't read it yet, but I've been eye-ing it in your margin. Thanks J (Comment this)

Written by: kbartha at 2005/08/22 - 14:43:10
4 - Guess who...

Great post, man. Whenever I get together with my care group we wind up talking about this issue, and it's a hot one. There's so much that "privileged" folks forget when it comes to this...

Keep it up, man.

Cheers, (Comment this)

Written by: Grey Owl at 2005/08/22 - 20:21:01
5 - Hey Grey Owl,

Thanks! I am so glad you've decided to add your voice to the Blogosphere! (Everyone keep an on his blog)

Peace,
Jamie (Comment this)

Written by: Jamie Arpin-Ricci at 2005/08/23 - 00:12:33
6 - Jamie,

great post. i appreciated when you said,

"This is not to say that we throw the doors open to unbridled permisiveness. Rather, acknowledging the complex and sensitive balance that needs to be found, create a world in which free will can be exercised responsibly and truly- meaning room must be made to fail. The Tree was in the Garden, after all."

this was on-point. i heard a preacher once say that we sometimes try to play the role of "holy spirit junior", thinking that we can convict the world of sin with out acknowledging that there is a "sensitive balance."

the other thing i sometimes observe is the categorization, and gradation of sin scale that many christians can own. people get angry about things like the ten commandments being removed, but don't get angry about racism, or unjust wars. jim wallis even talks about expanding the moral canvas beyond those things we traditionally label as sinful. he gives the example (in God's politics)of budget even acting as moral documents. which in a sense is true, because resource allocation determines where people's values lie.
 (Comment this)

Written by: jose h. at 2005/08/23 - 02:11:38
7 - jamie,

i noticed under books you're reading, you authored a book.

good stuff! (Comment this)

Written by: jose h. at 2005/08/23 - 02:42:25
8 - Jose,

Thanks. Great insights. I think you are right about categorization. Upon examination, the sins that get the attention of being the "worst" tend to be those that are "easy" targets, things so outside most Christians personal sphere, that they can affirm their "righteousness" by attacking an evil they will likely rarely, truly ever have to deal with first hand.

The book was a long work in progress I started in my early twenties and finally brought to print. Funny you should mention it today, as I just began chapter one of my next book.

Peace,
Jamie (Comment this)

Written by: Jamie Arpin-Ricci at 2005/08/23 - 04:42:12
9 - Dude, I don't know why but on your main page your sidebar is not on the side but rather in the main column under everything else. I thought it was just my computer being evil but on your comments page it looks normal. let me knw if I'm going crazy.

Cheers,

Dan-D from Canada/Grey Owl (Comment this)

Written by: Grey Owl at 2005/08/24 - 20:27:19
10 - Dan,

Not sure what the problem is, as I don't have it on my browser. What browser are you using?

Jamie (Comment this)

Written by: Jamie Arpin-Ricci at 2005/08/24 - 20:34:19
11 - I'm seeing it on 2 different comps, both using IE. Anyone else seeing this? (Comment this)

Written by: Grey Owl at 2005/08/25 - 06:32:23
12 - Hey Dan,

Alas, it is the cursed Internet Explorer. I am having it looked into. This is why we should all use Firefox. www.getfirefox.com

Jamie (Comment this)

Written by: Jamie Arpin-Ricci at 2005/08/25 - 16:18:32
13 - hey Jamie
nice blog. check out my bro's blog. i think you might enjoy his thoughts too. www.thisisquest.com/blog (Comment this)

Written by: Kristina at 2005/08/25 - 18:29:12
14 - Thanks Kristina! Great connection. Have you ever visited my YWAM blog? No one seems to. www.youthwithamission.blog.com

Also, Kim is now blogging. www.gracelet.blog.com

At any rate, we are praying that you will overcome the current challenges facing your next step!

Peace,
Jamie (Comment this)

Written by: Jamie Arpin-Ricci at 2005/08/25 - 18:40:49
15 - Hey Jamie,

I posted again to my site, I'd love your opinion.

Thanks,

Dan (Comment this)

Written by: Grey Owl at 2005/08/26 - 00:05:41
16 - Jamie, great post... I find myself really moved this morning as I read it.. I guess all too aware of my own weakness, too aware of what is at stake, sickened that so much of what the world knows of Jesus is just christian condemning sin..

Maybe the awareness of our own sinfulness is the best hope of the broken world.. It's only in our brokenness.. and in the broken body of Jesus.. that we offer hope.

"We are all in the gutter.. but some of us are looking at the stars" Oscar Wilde

Jesus, help us! (Comment this)

Written by: len at 2005/08/29 - 17:57:31
17 - Len,

As usual, you are able to capture in a few words the heart of things. Thanks for sharing that here. I think that you are right about the awareness of our own condition being one of our best hope.

Peace,
Jamie (Comment this)

Written by: Jamie Arpin-Ricci at 2005/08/29 - 18:05:16
Write a comment