October 01, 2007

Missional Casualties To Come


Recently I have been exploring the shift of the church in the West to more missional mindsets and practices.  It is really encouraging, especially in the Canadian context, to see this pattern reveal itself in the Body of Christ.  However, I have also begun to see (and feel) what some of the long term consequences of this shift will look like.

As a missionary with the (so called) "parachurch" organization Youth With A Mission (YWAM) for nearly 15 years, I have been able to serve in (what I an confident is) my vocation through the generous financial and prayer support of family, friends and churches.  However, in the last few years, we have seen a dramatic drop in our support, which we are now realizing is nearing a $10,000 annual drop.  We've been able to make some of this up through renting (though our tenents are missionaries, so we give them a significant break) and my writing (which is not consistent enough to be sustainable).  This has happened as the personal cost of being in ministry has went up.

I started doing some digging and found that one major factor for the drop has been that churches (and people in those churches) are giving more towards their own missional endeavours, thus not giving as much to outside missionaries, organizations and projects.  As many people believe that parachurch organizations exsist only because the church isn't doing all it is called to do, the result is that few feel they have any responsibility for the well being of those groups or individuals.  And so missionaries everywhere are seeing this decline.

Please don't get me wrong.  I am not saying people are selfishly or callously cutting us loose.  I am excited to see churches and Christians owning their missional role in the Body of Christ.  While I might argue that we need to find a way for these too often alienated groups (local vs. para) to work together for a mutually beneficial solution, this does not seem to be happening at this stage.  Again, I do not say this critically, but the power is with the local church and, unless they decide otherwise, this problem is not something to get many people's attention.

On a personal note, the result of this shift has led my wife & I the closest we have ever been to leaving the mission.  We entered into our calling with the assumption (perhaps naive) that the systems and relational supports that launched us into our ministry would always be there.  As adoption is likely to be the only way we will ever have children, and as the cost is so high, we face the possibility that our dream of a family will also be casualty.  So I find myself 30 years old with a high school diploma, few marketable skills, increasing debt and a ministry community who depends on our leadership.  I am tired, confused and, for the first time, genuinely scared.  We are not blaming anyone.  If anyone gets the blame, it is ourselves.

I truly believe that a coming trend that the emerging/missional church will need to respond to is how to honour and care for those people who have been faithful in older systems of missional service that, perhaps, are not longer sustainable given the new shift.  I know it is a real problem already for ourselves and for others in similar situations.

Which leads me to a small announcement: given the overwhelming stress we are under at this time, I am trying to find ways to take the burden off, and as a result will be taking a break from blogging here for an indeterminate period of time.  I hope I will be back soon, but I can't say for sure.  Your continued prayer is needed.


Posted by Jamie Arpin-Ricci at 13:09:39 | Permanent Link | Comments (35) |
Comments
1 - Jamie,
I will continue to pray for your financial situation - and also for the rapid return of your voice to the blog world. (Especially as you were the winner of last year's Canadian Blog Award for Best Religious Blog, eh!) (Comment this)

Written by: Bill Kinnon at 2007/10/01 - 13:35:08
2 - Praying for you and Kim, brother! May the Spirit give discernment, and peace. (Comment this)

Written by: Mike at 2007/10/01 - 13:41:32
3 - Praying, as per usual...
Dana (Comment this)

Written by: Anonymous at 2007/10/01 - 13:46:47
profile
4 - Bill, Mike & Dana,

Thanks all. We are really discouraged, but are believing the best. We believe- help us, Lord, in our unbelief!

Peace,
Jamie (Comment this)

Written by: voyageur at 2007/10/01 - 15:35:52
5 - Jamie, will be praying for you, the cost is high indeed :( (Comment this)

Written by: Paul at 2007/10/01 - 15:49:16
6 - prayer for sure - how about coffee too (Comment this)

Written by: bill at 2007/10/01 - 15:49:36
profile
7 - Hey Paul,

It is a high price, but again, I am not sure that it isn't the beginnings of an inevitable shift. I hope there can be a future that is more mutually formed, but I suspect that will be more of the exception than the rule- and again, I say this with no malice at all. Thanks!

Peace,
Jamie (Comment this)

Written by: voyageur at 2007/10/01 - 15:54:00
profile
8 - Hey Bill,

Thanks. Connect for coffee would be great. I'll drop you an email.

Peace,
Jamie (Comment this)

Written by: voyageur at 2007/10/01 - 15:54:37
9 - Thanks for posting your thoughts Jamie.

I've been thinking long and hard about the complexity of ministry today. As a member of the nonprofit field, I think it's safe to say that most nonprofit organizations are worried because the old paradigm of fundraising may change unless the baby boom generation becomes very generous fast. Philanthropy and giving just ain't what they used to be.

On the other hand, if organizations try to pick up the slack through volunteers . . . people are also becoming overworked and too busy, especially with both parents working in so many households. In short, the nonprofit world may become a mess in the near future.

So it seems that part of what you're experiencing may be part of a larger trend. Figuring out how to support ministry in this changing world is a real challenge for Christin missionaries and organizations. I would like to encourage you that your blogging is a tremendous ministry that I value greatly.

Will be praying for guidance as you walk through this valley. (Comment this)

Written by: ed c at 2007/10/01 - 20:41:58
profile
10 - Ed,

Exactly. Thank you for your prayers.

Peace,
Jamie (Comment this)

Written by: voyageur at 2007/10/01 - 20:44:28
11 - Thanks for posting your thoughts Jamie.

I've been thinking long and hard about the complexity of ministry today. As a member of the nonprofit field, I think it's safe to say that most nonprofit organizations are worried because the old paradigm of fundraising may change unless the baby boom generation becomes very generous fast. Philanthropy and giving just ain't what they used to be.

On the other hand, if organizations try to pick up the slack through volunteers . . . people are also becoming overworked and too busy, especially with both parents working in so many households. In short, the nonprofit world may become a mess in the near future.

So it seems that part of what you're experiencing may be part of a larger trend. Figuring out how to support ministry in this changing world is a real challenge for Christin missionaries and organizations. I would like to encourage you that your blogging is a tremendous ministry that I value greatly.

Will be praying for guidance as you walk through this valley. (Comment this)

Written by: ed c at 2007/10/01 - 20:45:40
profile
12 - LOL! Again, good thoughts, Ed. (Comment this)

Written by: voyageur at 2007/10/01 - 20:49:18
13 - Jamie,

I think that a shift is coming as well. I don't know what it will look like, and I don't know what God has for you, so I will pray. (Comment this)

Written by: Mary at 2007/10/01 - 22:19:57
profile
14 - Thanks Mary. Part of me keeps wishing the answer(s) will suddenly show themselves and all will be at peace in our lives, but somehow I know that isn't going to be the way of it. Alas!

Peace,
Jamie (Comment this)

Written by: voyageur at 2007/10/01 - 22:23:45
15 - " I truly believe that a coming trend that the emerging/missional church will need to respond to is how to honour and care for those people who have been faithful in older systems of missional service that, perhaps, are not longer sustainable given the new shift."

Jamie, I also think there are communities struggling to sustain what they have ,and trying to launch into ther missional projects when they might be better off supporting projects that are already ongoing...maybe supporting and partnering with them.

You, Kim and your ministry are in my prayers...your presence will be missed. Peace...Ron +


 (Comment this)

Written by: the weary pilgrim at 2007/10/02 - 04:30:46
16 - Hi Jamie!

I'm amazed at the similarities in our stories. I too went into vocaional church planting ministry in 2001 beliving that the support systems would also be there for us. Our ministry was reaching people primarily in the lower income demographic, teens, and college students so our income was limited by the income of those we were reaching. I tried desperately to find bi-vocational work, but couldn't.

My wife and I too began to see that adoption was to be our only means of having a family. In 2005, at 37 years old I threw in the towel and left vocational ministry. And I've regretted it ever since.

Nonetheless, as part of our five-year plan, I am now in school (sitting in my classroom as I type) learning skills that will enable me to support myself in the marketplace as my wife and I return to planting missional communities among those who don't know Christ...and doing so without the emotional drain of having to be supported through that ministry. Our adoption is also underway.

Hang in there Jamie. Discover what you love, figure out how to support yourself through it, and by all means don't ever abandon the calling to make disciples for the King.
 (Comment this)

Written by: Bill Huffhine at 2007/10/02 - 06:26:55
profile
17 - Hey Ron,

Thanks. I agree and hope for a future where there are mutually beneficial partnerships that are not dependent on denominations, etc. We'll see!

Peace,
Jamie (Comment this)

Written by: voyageur at 2007/10/02 - 08:50:27
profile
18 - Hey Bill,

It is a real comfort to know that we are not alone in this journey. I am so excited for where your journey has brought you and the doors it seems to be opening. Thanks for the encouragement.

Peace,
Jamie (Comment this)

Written by: voyageur at 2007/10/02 - 08:51:34
19 - Jamie,
I know you need to find God's way for you in this so will be praying for you.

I get the sense that we need to be doing more than that. May I contact you by e-mail? (Comment this)

Written by: Linea Lanoie at 2007/10/02 - 11:30:44
profile
20 - Linea,

I got your email. I look forward to connecting with you guys. Thank you so much.

Peace,
Jamie (Comment this)

Written by: voyageur at 2007/10/02 - 12:48:56
21 - Jamie,

Being out of missions and working for a church now, I haven't thought through some of those consequences. Do you find that there are many missionaries experiencing this? I hear the same reports coming out of the base I used to serve at.

Now i know how to pray. i will be praying. Don't give up on adoption just yet brother. God has been faithful to my wife and i through our process (which is almost over)and i would hope he would do the same for you.

peace. (Comment this)

Written by: joe at 2007/10/02 - 13:27:34
profile
22 - Hey Joe,

Yes, it is a pattern throughout YWAM and other agencies. It is also that many new pastors/church planters are experiencing too. Your prayers are appreciated.

As for adoption, we are holding on to hope. Sadly, Canadian red tap makes it much hard and more expensive to adopt here than in the States. Alas!

Peace,
Jamie (Comment this)

Written by: voyageur at 2007/10/02 - 13:35:07
23 - Jamie, I shall miss not reading your thoughts, and look forward to your return - when and if that happens. Thank you for all you have given to the people who read your blog. You are an amazing man and have a lot to offer. Praying that adoption is a real possibility for you and Kim. Take care of yourself. (Comment this)

Written by: Lyn at 2007/10/03 - 10:27:38
profile
24 - Lyn,

Thank you so much. I hope to return too. We are working to see how we can continue in our calling in this time of transition. Your prayer and friendship means a great deal.

Peace,
Jamie (Comment this)

Written by: voyageur at 2007/10/03 - 10:32:35
25 - Jamie,
I, too, am in parachurch ministry (CCO). As a leader in this ministry, we've had a crisis of sorts this year as well, trying to intentionally get everyone up to their full support. But churches are giving less as they see parachurch as not legitimate mission, and individual people are giving less as they are...well, giving less (I'll let that statement stand on its own).

My own personal support is only at about 75%, and if I don't find more supporters, I too will be in your shoes.

You are in my prayers. And the church will be in my prayers too. (Comment this)

Written by: Bob Robinson at 2007/10/06 - 07:41:19
profile
26 - Hey Bob,

Perhaps I have been unaware, but this problem seems to have "snuck up" on us. I keep praying that the crisis will birth something new. You are in our prayers as we seek God in this time. Thanks!

Peace,
Jamie (Comment this)

Written by: voyageur at 2007/10/06 - 07:56:00
27 - Jamie,
As others have commented, Julie and I are experienced in the bewilderment, pressure and fear that you are facing. After 23 years as Teaching Pastor in a nice-size evangelical church, I resigned not knowing where we'd end up. It was traumatic in many ways. Yet, the old hymn "Be Still, My Soul" was true..."in every change He faithful will remain." You are in our prayers as you are led by the Good and Great and Chief Shepherd to the next place in your kingdom work. You are a highly gifted thinker and writer and our Good King will have a place for you. (Comment this)

Written by: John at 2007/10/06 - 09:45:17
profile
28 - John,

Thank you for your understanding, encouragement and prayer. As difficult as this is, we also believe that this could be the beginning of a new approach to ministry. Thanks!

Peace,
Jamie (Comment this)

Written by: voyageur at 2007/10/06 - 10:13:17
29 - Jamie - I don't know you, have appreciated your writing, know your name from JesusCreed.org. Just a response to your comment on adoption - we have adopted 2 children from foster care and it did not cost us a dime. We would love to discuss this with you if you're open to it. steph (at) stephanieseefeldt (dot) com.
all blessing to you!

 (Comment this)

Written by: Anonymous at 2007/10/06 - 21:42:08
profile
30 - Hey Steph,

Thanks. I'll contact offline.

Peace,
Jamie (Comment this)

Written by: voyageur at 2007/10/06 - 22:13:37
31 - Given your real mission, I hope you'll see this disaster ultimately as a great success. You have shared in the stimulation of new growth along the edges! Yet I know the pain of this financial crisis; my prayers are with you and yours. (Comment this)

Written by: David at 2007/10/07 - 21:28:09
profile
32 - David,

Thank you for you encouragement. On an encouraging note, our immediate financial crisis is slowly improving. Now we have to work towards a creative, sustainable future. Thanks!

Peace,
Jamie (Comment this)

Written by: voyageur at 2007/10/07 - 22:36:55
33 - Jamie,

I followed the trail to your blog via the TPFKATC conversation.

Sorry to read about your plight. It certainly seems that at times (Comment this)

Written by: Volkmar at 2007/10/21 - 20:45:21
34 - (my first attempt didn't post completely)


Jamie,

I followed the trail to your blog via the TPFKATC conversation.

Sorry to read about your plight. It certainly seems that at times "trouble" really piles on.

One of our sons-in-law's parents have been with YWAM for more than 20 years. They are getting ready to move to Nicaragua to remain full time training teachers. As far as I know they are ok with their support, but I suspect that is so because of their long standing support base that has been loyal for a long period of time.

My wife and I are actively involved with a group of Believers who (happen to) meet in our residence. We consider ourself directly doing "mission", but yet we've always paid our bills by working in a trade--livestock production. We got our last livestock check about three weeks ago. It had been an extremely un-profitable situation for the last couple of years and that trend accelerated when so much of the corn crop began to turned into auto fuel. We liquidated the sow herd. Big change in our lives. We don't really know what we're going to do for income. We do believe that we've followed God's direction in this, so we also trust that He will provide us with a source of income.

So, I guess I'd say that we all seem to be subject to some new "trends". Exciting times ahead.

Tom (aka Volkmar)

 (Comment this)

Written by: Volkmar at 2007/10/21 - 20:48:04
profile
35 - Volkmar,

I'll be praying that God will lead you into His provision. Thanks for you your kind words and encouragement. Feel free to check me out at my new blog www.missional.blog.com

Peace,
Jamie (Comment this)

Written by: Jamie Arpin-Ricci at 2007/10/21 - 21:10:08
Write a comment