(e)mergent Voyageurs

A recent comment on my post revealed an assumption held by many emerging church critics that I had thought was beginning to fade (and I still hope is). That is that Brian McLaren (and ones stance on him) is a litmus test for all things emerging/emergent. Not only are his writings used as the measure of what every emerging Christian believes, but his name is raised with an inquisitional intent when people are trying to determine someones flawed (and often heretical) beliefs.

I have read much of what McLaren has written, both in his books and online articles. I have also had the opportunity to correspond with him a few times via email. I have learned a great deal from him, challenged by his ideas, touched by his pastoral heart. Do I agree with everything he teaches? Of course not. I say this, not to distance myself to him, but rather to acknowledge that simple fact, a fact that is true of most other people.

I cannot help but ask myself what it must be like to be Brian McLaren. While he certainly choose to put himself and his ideas out there through publishing and public speaking, he never signed up to be the figurehead of a movement. I have no doubt he has great joy for his part in what is becoming an increasingly wide spread conversation (aka movement), but few are as aware as him as to the personal cost it has exacted of him. I do not envy him the experience of reading and hearing the harsh judgments and unequivical condemnation that are so often leveled against him.

The fact is that Brian is man of God, called and gifted by God in his own unique ways. He is a pastor, a leader, a writer, a husband, a father, a friend- he is human. He makes mistakes like the rest of us. One could argue that a higher standard is held to him for his rule as pastor and public figure. Fair enough. I have little doubt that McLaren is painfully aware of this himself, bringing him to time of deep prayer and reflection.

So why am I writing this post? First, it is simply that, upon recently having the above stated assumptions brought up here on this blog, I found myself considering what it must be like to be in his shoes. And while I am sure his life is filled with joy and fulfilment, I could not help but consider the potential pain, frustration and alienation he must feel.

Second, I want to clarify my "position" on Brian McLaren (as ridiculous as that is) so that we are clear. Brian McLaren does not speak for all of the emerging/emergent/missional movement. His writings cannot and should not be taken as the measure of our theology, ecclesiology, eschatology, etc. He is NOT the figurehead of all things emerging. That being said, he IS a pastor of great compassion and gifting. He IS a teacher respected a loved. He IS one or many important voices, even leaders, to many in the emerging-missional conversation. Above all, without a second of hesitation, I believe he IS a brother in Christ.

If you are a critic who sees McLaren as a heretic or believe he has nothing to offer the church, you are entitled to your opinion, but I will not debate that point with you here. I seek to make this blog a welcome place for all perspectives, so if you are genuinely open to explore some ideas, let's talk. However, if you want simply to denounce McLaren (or me for my support of him), then this won't be the place.

The final reason this is important to me to write is that I owe a great deal to McLaren for the development of my own journey. He was used by God to open my heart and mind and choices to a faith that is richer and fuller. Even in wrestling through issues and ideas that I would later disagree with him on, I benefited from the engagement. So ultimately, it is out of gratitude to this brother that I write this post.

Thanks Brian.