Seeking Identity Through Diversity

This past weekend, my wife & I had some time to relax, so decided to rent a movie. As Kim is the athlete in the marraige, we choose sports films from time to time. This time Kim decided on “The Rocket”. In this excellent historical true story, the life and career of legendary Québécois hockey player Maurice “The Rocket” Richard. Those who know of The Rocket’s career will know that he was one of the most masterful players to ever play the game, but also the source of great controversy.
Richard played in an area where French Canadians were often treated as second rate citizens by other Canadians (and often as poorly by American teams and fans). Matching his talent on the ice with pointed critique of the inequity within the National Hockey League against French Canadians, reflecting the deeper prejudice that permeated the larger culture. This injustice played itself out during game play, which Richard reacted to forcefully. While his violence was perhaps excessive, if understandable, in 1955 it earned him a suspension for the remain season and the playoffs. The result was a massive riot by fans which remains infamous to this day.
Watching this film stirred something in me, perhaps even opening a deep and long forgotten wound. As many of you know, my family on my mothers side is French Canadian. The heritage of the Aprin/Trudeau family (yes, Pierre was a relative) are rich, rooted in this nation since before the Battle on the Plains of Abraham. And yet, like many of my cousins, the French heritage has been lost to me. I do not speak French (though I understand a fair bit) and have lost much of the cultural characteristics that were once a part of our families life. Several years ago I added “Arpin” to my last name as an attempt to honour that part of my history, but I have found it difficult to do more to recapture it.
Perhaps this is why the issue of my previous two posts (Redemptive Taxonomy & Why I Am…) were so personal for me. I do not want to add dividing labels or brands, nor do I want split the church into opposing camps. However, I know how misguded we can get at times, even with the best intentions, in trying to forge unity through uniformity. People keep saying this like “Can’t we just be followers of Christ?” or “We should find our identity in Christ”. Of course I agree with this, but these comments tend to be more sentimental than substantial, doing nothing to work through the real issues of our diversity.
I don’t want to beat a dead horse with this issue. However, I wanted to shed some light as to one of the reasons why this has been so important to me. I haven’t wanted to put things in boxes. I haven’t wanted to contribute to division or parochialism. I haven’t been attempting distance myself from one group/theology or another. Rather, my desire has been to try to contribute to an environment that allows for the diversity that is so essential to our identities within Christ and to our unity as His Body.
Ok, I promise to move on and mix up the topics this week. Au revoir!
Hi Jamie,
Long time no talk to. Yeah, you are working through some of the same stuff that me and Ant and other African-American bloggers are grappling with. This is the whole point of both the Tower of Babel and the story of Pentecost in my view. God is not against cultural diversity, He is the author of it, but yet and still, with all of your diversity, He still calls us to be one. Not to be uniformally one, but in the midst of diversity, to agree that He is God and Lord of all.
Perhaps the new song we sing in heaven is simply a blending of human cultural diversity? I guess God is too big to squeeze into just one ethnic cultural reality.
Marc,
People like you and Ant have contributed a great deal to shaping my involvement in the conversation, so I dearly appreciate your words here. I share your hope and vision for that new song.
Peace,
Jamie
Jamie, as a 1/2 french Canadian my self (my mothers madien name being Rondeau) I too feel a connection to what your saying. I have regretted for the past couple years how I ignorantly rejected that part of my heritage and as such have been trying to repent of it since. still can’t speak a lick. anyway just wanted to say thanks for your post and let you know I agree with the thoughts that are being communicated about God being the Author of Culture and desiring to see the body unique yet unified. I will continue to press into my heritage more. Thanks bro!
Hi Jamie…love the title of the post ” Diversity as an Identity “, I think I may hve flipped it…but the meaning is the same. It is such an open ended statement.
Ryan,
I am glad you shared that. Few people understand how it feels. I was talking to a friend of mine whose grandparents were 3 white Americans and one African American. She mentioned that, despite the fact that she could be referred to as only 1/4 African American, her appearance will always connect her to that heritage. French Canadians who lose that connection have no such visible connection. Thanks for sharing, bro.
Peace,
Jamie
Ron,
Yeah, it would have worked either way. Thanks!
Peace,
Jamie